Sarah’s on Central

• • • • • • • • • • •



Sarah’s on Central

Sarah’s On Central in Eureka, MO

Our neighborhood restaurant is dedicated to creating an inviting space where community members can gather and enjoy good food, desserts and drinks. We are committed to continuous improvement, listening to feedback from patrons, and evolving our offerings to meet the changing desires and needs of our community.

food for the entire family!

A Sweet Gathering Place

Sarah’s On Central in Eureka, MO

Eureka offers not only our delicious desserts, specialty cakes and cupcakes but some unique spins on cafe cuisine.


Sarah’s On Central in Eureka, MO
  • Just wanted to thank you for the beautiful job on the cupcakes and desserts for Holly’s wedding. The table looked beautiful and everyone really enjoyed all your yummy treats! It was a pleasure working with you via email since I was so far away in the planning of the wedding but all went well and I appreciate all you did to make the cake/dessert portion of the event special and tasty!

  • I just wanted to write and say a big THANK YOU to the creators of the best-tasting, most beautiful wedding cake ever! All of our guests raved about our cake, and we absolutely loved it. It turned out so beautifully ... a true work of art! I will definitely recommend your shop to any friends who get married in the Saint Louis area!

  • I just wanted to thank you so much for the fabulous job on the cake and cupcakes. They were DELICIOUS and people literally can't stop talking about them!!! Thank you so much!

  • A special thanks; Sarah and Allan's wedding cake was scrumptious! In total, the wedding weekend was fabulous!!! Also, I've asked The Chase catering/event dept. to add your shop to their preferred vendor's list, and they agreed to do so.

  • Oh my goodness, Marie and Michael's cake was sooo delicious, and I'm not even a big cake fan. I had the chocolate and it was just wonderful. The presentation and fondant flowers looked gorgeous. I hope we work together again soon and I won't hesitate to recommend Sarah's Cake Shop to future clients.

  • Thank you for the cupcakes. They were delicious!!!! Everyone said they were beautiful and the icing was wonderful. Thank you for delivering them to Chaumette!!!!

  • I wanted to let you know that the cake you guys made was fabulous! It looked very nice and tasted good as well. So thank you and your team on a job well done.

  • Just wanted to let you know how satisfied we were with the outstanding job you did on our daughter's wedding cake last Saturday at the Doubletree. It was the best ever and we received so many compliments on it. It was absolutely delicious, moist and beautiful--- Please feel free to use us as a reference if anyone ever needs one.

    Becky & Larry
  • I cannot thank you enough for your personal investment you made into Grace and Hunter’s wedding preparation with the various meetings, suggestions, and personal touches. Your warm and kind spirit gave me, the customer, a sense that we would be well cared for. The dessert table was amazingly beautiful. The comments about your presentation were so complementary. Your eye for detail and arrangement made each item stand out individually. It was picture perfect. Thank you again Erica for your kindness, patience throughout all the changes, and the remarkable customer service. You were a part of a symphony of wonderful people who came together to create a magical evening for Grace and Hunter

  • Hello! I just need to say THANK YOU THANK YOU for the gorgeous wedding cake! Dan and I loved it! It was so pretty and of course tasted excellent. Our guests totally raved about it. From my first phone call you were so nice and responsive and I very much appreciate you! Before the wedding I was already recommending Sarah’s but for sure now I will be. We have some left over and in the freezer, but I have a feeling it won’t be there much longer. Thanks again for making our wedding beautiful and delicious

    Stephanie & Dan
  • Thank you for all your time, energy and ideas on creating the perfect dessert table and cake design. The line for the dessert table was longer than the line for the bar and people are still talking about it! Everything looked and tasted great, and we owe it all to you!

    Sheila & Alex
  • I just wanted to say thank you for my beautiful wedding cake. It completely exceeded my expectations. It was so beautiful I couldn’t stop looking at it and I about died when I had to cut it. I wish I had a sculpture of it to keep forever. I know my photographer got some great pictures of it! I was also SO delicious. Everyone loved it and I bragged about how amazing Sarah’s is! Thank you for creating my dream wedding cake!

  • Thank you so much for helping make my wedding such a memorable evening. The cupcakes and cake were not only PERFECT in color and presentation, but were fantastically delicious. You were a hut! Thank you for being so easy to deal with and for your professionalism.

  • It was so great to work with you to create the perfect cake for our wedding. You did an amazing job! The cake turned out even more beautifully than either of us had imagined. We received so many complements on our cake. It was delicious! Thank you again for all your hard work and we look forward to seeing you again for our 1 year anniversary! Perhaps we will make the cake tier an annual tradition!

    Marie & Michael
  • Thank you so much for all of your time, effort and hard work you put into our beautiful and delicious cake! If was everything we dreamed of!

    Katie & Chris
  • Thank you so much for making the process of choosing a wedding cake so easy and delicious! The cake looked great and tasted heavenly at the reception. I am referring all of my engaged friends to you.

  • Thank you so much for all you did to help make our wedding day perfect. The cake and glitter bites were the best hit! People are still talking about them! Thanks again.



our gallery

Sarah’s On Central in Eureka, MO


127 S. Central Ave.
Eureka, MO 63025

call us



Wednesday & Thursday 7:30am-5pm
Friday & Saturday 7:30am-8pm
Shop open an hour later or until business declines
Sunday 8am-2pm

-Check Out Our-

-We no longer have our Cake Stop Truck-
but we can still take orders for your favorite truck stop desserts!